Friday, February 02, 2007

Crtitical changes in PA dog laws

Remember, when one of us has our rights infringed upon, we ALL lose that right!

A SAOVA message for sportsmen, pet owners and farmers concerned about protecting their traditions, avocations and livelihoods from anti-hunting, anti-breeding, animal guardianship advocates. Forwarding and cross posting, with attribution, encouraged.
Dear Pennsylvania Dog Owning Friends,

This is a crucial message. Please read it carefully, share it with other dog owners, your family and friends and, most importantly, take the action recommended. The new statewide dog kennel regulations proposed on December 16, 2006 has been widely circulated, but they're impact hasn't been well documented, nor has a plan to defeat them been formulated. Recent Virginia advocacy efforts have made it difficult to address these ill-considered regulations before now. I'm taking advantage of another man's analysis, which is reproduced below. This state regulation can be defeated in the next two weeks, but only with your concerted and dedicated actions, together with significant help..

Be acutely aware that, as was the case of Senator's Santorum's discredited and defeated Pet Animal Welfare Statute (PAWS), a simple reduction in this regulation's 26 dog licensed kennel definition could trap many more reputable Pennsylvania hobby breeders and everyday dog owners, perhaps you. Here is the result of a very well respected, long-time professional dog trainer's review of the posted regulations' impact on him.

New Pennsylvania Kennel Regulations
Threaten Trainers, Breeders, Competitors

HARRISBURG, Pa. – A proposed revision in the regulations to enforce Pennsylvania’s existing kennel law would impose severe mandates on many dog trainers and breeders, is expected to put many kennels out of business, and imposes heavy fines and confiscation of dogs for noncompliance.

The Pennsylvania Bureau of Dog Law Enforcement, an arm of the state Department of Agriculture, estimates that it will cost every licensed kennel in Pennsylvania between $5,000 and $20,000 to come into compliance with the new rules. Many kennel owners peg the cost as much higher. The Bureau also estimates its own costs at $15,000 initially for each of its dog wardens, plus $5,000 annually for each warden. The wardens are funded through kennel license fees. The Bureau maintains that there will be no cost to the general public, but the document does not consider that charges for services (boarding and training), or for the sale of puppies, dogs and stud services, will have to be increased to cover the additional costs borne by the kennels that survive.

Supporters of the measure argue that the stricter rules are needed to control alleged “puppy mills,” which they claim are common in Pennsylvania. Opponents of the measure say that the new rules represent an escalation of the “animal rights” agenda aimed at eliminating commercial animal operations, private ownership of animals and hunting. They allege that the “animal rights” groups see this measure as a victory as it will eliminate most kennels in Pennsylvania, thereby reducing the number and availability of privately owned dogs, and set a precedent that eventually would accord the same “rights” to farm animals and wild animals.

All kennels that house, buy, sell or raise more than 26 dogs or puppies a year are required to be licensed, and are subject to all of the provisions of the new rules.

The impact of the new rules on dog competitions in Pennsylvania remains to be seen. The rules call for current veterinary and rabies certificates for any dog entering the state, would appear to make the sizes of standard dog boxes, topper holes and airline crates insufficient, and would appear to make chain gangs and stakeouts illegal.

There are four basic thrusts to the new regulations:

Strict requirements for improving kennel facilities. These new requirements would double the minimum size of kennel runs. For a typical bird dog, the smallest legal kennel would be six-feet wide and 15-feet long. Dog boxes would have to be large enough to allow a dog to lie on its belly or side, so that no part of its body, including its tail, could touch the sides; for a typical bird dog, a box would have to be at least five feet square to comply. For a typical bird dog kept on a chain, the chains would have to be at least 15 feet long. Waterproof solid shade structures would have to be built over part of each outdoor kennel and area for chained dogs. There also are many other new physical requirements for construction, surfacing and maintenance.

Detailed and time-consuming management requirements. Among the new rules are requirements for each dog and puppy in the kennel to be exercised individually on a leash for 20 minutes a day. Allowing a dog to run free at the kennel or when hunting, training or exercising, would not meet this requirement. The rules also excludes conditioning activities such as roading in groups. The exercise and leash requirements apply even to dogs kept in the kennel owner’s home. Other rules would require daily sanitation of all kennels, panels, houses and bowls, and daily changes of bedding material. Dogs would have to be removed from the kennel during sanitation, and not be put back in until all surfaces had been dried. For people who work with dogs, onsite shower facilities must be provided.

Restrictions on how licensed kennels could do business. A licensed kennel would not be allowed to purchase a dog from a private party, interstate sales would be strictly regulated and subject to inspection, sources of dogs and puppies could be investigated for dog law violations in any state, no dogs or puppies could be transported into or out of the state without a veterinary health certificate and rabies certificate, new dogs coming into the kennel (such as for training) would be subject to quarantine and veterinary inspection in certain instances (including signs of worms), all new puppies brought to a kennel would have to be quarantined for 14 days, and dogs would have to be strictly segregated according to size and gender. Short-haired dogs, which would include pointers, many Continental breeds and hounds, could not be kept in outdoor facilities when the temperature falls below 35 degrees, and all breeds in any kind of facility would require cooling when temperatures are above 85 degrees. In order to purchase a dog from a kennel out of state, the kennel would have to be licensed and subject to the approval of Pennsylvania agencies.

Many record-keeping requirements. The new regulations impose a host of new forms, mandated bills of sale, and paperwork requirements. For example, no fewer than six separate forms would have to be completed each day for each dog in a kennel. These includes individual daily records for exercising, feeding and watering, sanitizing bowls, sanitizing the kennel, cleaning the kennel and cleaning houses. For a kennel containing 50 dogs, these individual forms would require completing 300 different forms every day. Records for each dog must be kept for two years.

I can state with absolute certainty that these proposed regulatory changes will put me out of business, and I think they will put many other kennels in the state out of business, too. In fact, I don't know of a single kennel anywhere that could meet the new standards. Even the most modern and fancy kennels that I know would not meet the standards in the proposed regulations.


These changes are not proposed legislation, are not subject to a vote of the state House and Senate, and will not require the signature of Gov. Ed Rendell. The measure rewrites regulations based on existing law. They interpret the law, describe enforcement procedures and impose penalties. The measure is before the Pennsylvania Independent Regulatory Review Commission. The Commission consists of four members appointed by each party in the House and Senate, and one member appointed by Rendell, who supports the new rules.

The Commission will accept public comments until Feb. 15. Following the deadline, the Commission has 20 days to accept, reject or call for modifications to the regulations. The result is published a second time, and then immediately carries the force of law. There is a provision that does allow for the new regulations to be reviewed by the Senate and House Agriculture Committees, at their option.

In SAOVA's experience with such proposed agency regulations, the most effective way to block such measures is to pull out all the stops - contact the press, veterinarians, legislators, bureaucrats, other dog owners, farmers, vendors, family, friends, et. al. Make a long distribution list. Get everyone involved.

The PA Agriculture Department is inviting you and the public to submit written comments, suggestions, questions or objections. Even if you have no suggestions or objections and support the proposed regulation, please consider writing to the Department. By law, the Department is required to give each commentator (any organization or person that submits comments during the public comment period) the opportunity to request notice concerning the final version of this regulation. The Department may revise or change the regulation between the proposed and final stages of the rulemaking process. By commenting on the proposed regulation, you will also get a chance to review any changes to the regulation before it is published as a final rule.
Written comments on the proposed regulation should be sent to the following person and address:

Department of Agriculture
Bureau of Dog Law Enforcement
Attn: Mary Bender
2301 North Cameron Street
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110-9408
Telephone: (717) 787-3062

The last day to submit comments on this proposed regulation is February 14, 2007.
The Independent Regulatory Review Commission (IRRC) is also interested in your comments on the regulation. Please "cc" IRRC on your comments to the Agriculture Department by sending a copy to the following person and address:

Arthur Coccodrilli, Chairman
Independent Regulatory Review Commission See website for more e-addresses
333 Market Street, 14th Floor
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Main Telephone: (717) 783-5417
Fax: (717) 783-2664

Please identify the regulation on your comments by using the regulation
ID #2-152 (#2559).

This proposed regulation will also be submitted to the House and Senate Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committees for their review in the new session in 2007. You definitely want to contact these Committees and your individual State Representatives and State Senators about this proposal See attachments for Harrisburg info. These are your most important contacts, IMO.

Contact the Farm Bureau headquarters and local county office.

Call your veterinarian and the PA Veterinary Medical Association
Ask for their help. Tell them all who you are, where you live and why these proposed unreasonable, unworkable kennel regulations should be discarded.

Kindly circulate this message widely.

Bob Kane Sportsmen's and Animal Owners' Voting Alliance -Issue lobbying and working to identify and elect supportive legislatorsHelp fund our pro-animal owner advocacy via PayPal

No comments: